City to homeowner: Let us in, or get out! Man evicted from house for resisting warrantless inspections

Sunday, October 04, 2009

WorldNetDaily Exclusive

City to homeowner: Let us in, or get out
Man evicted from house for resisting warrantless inspections

Posted: October 04, 2009
11:33 pm Eastern

By Drew Zahn


City notice posted on Michael Marcavage’s duplex

A Pennsylvania man who refuses to allow city officials to enter his home without a warrant has been forced out to stay in a hotel instead, evicted by a notice posted on his door that forbids him from using or occupying the building he owns.

Borough Ordinance No. 1188 of Lansdowne, Penn., requires all rental properties – including the private residence of the landlord, if he lives onsite – be subjected to annual inspections, with or without a warrant.

But Michael Marcavage, who lives in half of a Lansdowne duplex he owns, renting out the other half, believes the city knocking on the door and demanding warrantless entrance and inspection of his private residence – just because it also happens to be part of a rental building – is a violation of the U.S. Constitution’s Fourth Amendment.

The Fourth Amendment states in part, “The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause.”

Marcavage has not been accused of any wrongdoing, nor has any warrant been sought to inspect his property. In fact, he’s been fighting the borough’s rental inspection ordinance as unconstitutional for years, both for himself and his tenants. He’s even been issued a citation and fine in the past for refusing to permit warrantless search of his home.

But earlier this week, the borough stepped up the battle.

Two days ago, city code officials posted a notice on Marcavage’s door informing him his house was deemed an “unlawful rental property” and allowing him to the end of that same day to obtain his rental license or get out.

Now Marcavage is staying at a hotel, but he vows to fight the city’s ordinance and actions in federal court, if necessary.

“I cannot and will not bow to these tyrannical actions by government officials,” Marcavage stated. “The notice posted on my front door was not only a notice to me, but a notice to all Americans, that if you are unwilling to forsake your constitutional rights, the government will make you suffer.”

WND contacted Michael Jozwiak, Lansdowne’s director of zoning and code enforcement, who said Marcavage’s talk of inspections was “putting the cart before the horse.”

“The notice says nothing about inspections,” Jozwiak explained. “Mr. Marcavage failed to file for his rental license, and that’s the reason for the notice.”

But Marcavage told WND the dispute still comes down to mandatory entry into his home and the homes of his tenants. He intentionally refused to sign the renewal forms Jozwiak alluded to, because they required compliance with the city’s warrantless search ordinance.

“I could not in good conscience agree to the terms of the license renewal, thus signing away my Fourth Amendment rights,” Marcavage said. “I explained this to Mr. Jozwiak and sent him U.S. Supreme Court rulings demonstrating the city’s ordinance as unconstitutional. I even offered to file the necessary forms unsigned.”

Marcavage highlighted the 1967 Camara v. Municipal Court of City and County of San Francisco case, in which the Supreme Court overturned conviction of a tenant for refusing a housing code inspection.

“We hold that administrative searches of the kind at issue here are significant intrusions upon the interests protected by the Fourth Amendment,” the court ruled, “that such searches when authorized and conducted without a warrant procedure lack the traditional safeguards which the Fourth Amendment guarantees to the individual.”

Marcavage also told WND that he is seeking an injuction that would enable him to move back into his home without violating the notice posted on his door and possibly risking an arrest.

“We’ve got to defend our rights,” Marcavage said, “especially after the Supreme Court’s recent decisions on eminent domain.”

Marcavage also pointed to a case in Red Wing, Minn., to argue that it’s not just renters and landlords that need to be concerned about the erosion of the Fourth Amendment.

In the 2006 case of Stewart v. City of Red Wing, landlords similarly rejected the city’s attempt to require warrantless code inspections. During the case, however, it was discovered city officials were considering the inspection of rental properties as only a first step, before seeking the ability to inspect all private residences in the city.

Though Red Wing has since explicitly backed away from the plan to inspect all homes, Marcavage warns Americans need to remain vigilant:

“I believe it was Thomas Jefferson,” Marcavage said, “who warned of the government encroaching on our rights, not all at once, but in increments.”


Leave a comment

No comments yet.

Comments RSS TrackBack Identifier URI

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

  • NEXT:

  • Signs of the times




  • *************

  • [clearspring_widget title=""Gone" Barack Obama" wid="4974d21ab04fa9e2" pid="4af852b10cc93051" width="207" height="305" domain=""] Barack Obama Countdown widget brought to you by
  • RSS American Spectator

    • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.
  • RSS Sweetness & Light

    • After Ten Years, Sweetness & Light Is Taking ‘A Hiatus’ August 13, 2015
      Where does the time go? As of Saturday August 15th, S&L will have been laboring in the vineyard that is the internet for a full ten years. So I am taking a little break. Maybe even a big break. I will keep you posted. I want to thank the extended S&L family for your interest and comments and generous financial support over the years. Thank you all ve […]
    • Sketch Of Tom Brady Draws Apology From ‘Court Artist’ August 13, 2015
      In the NYT piece on this, the artist said (paraphrasing) ‘that it’s harder to draw celebrities, because people know what they look like.’ From the New York Daily News: Ugly courtroom sketch of Tom Brady goes viral and draws an apology from artist Jane Rosenberg By Stephen Rex Brown, Larry Mcshane | August 12, 2015 Welcome to Deface-gate. A courtroom artist’s […]
    • CNN Poll: Trump Best With Issues, Mostly Likely To Win August 13, 2015
      Apparently Trump represents hope and change — or at least hope for change — to a lot of Republicans. From a gobsmacked CNN: CNN / ORC Poll: Trump tops in Iowa as Scott Walker drops By Jennifer Agiesta | August 12, 2015 Washington (CNN) — Donald Trump has a significant lead in the race to win over likely Iowa caucus-goers, according to the first CNN/ORC poll […]
    • WH: Defunding Planned Parenthood ‘Could Break Law’ August 13, 2015
      Notice how quickly the White House has stepped in here to stop the states from defunding of Planned Parenthood. Meanwhile, the Obama White House has yet to say one word against PP selling baby parts for profit. Why is that? From The Hill: WH warns states: Defunding Planned Parenthood might break law By Peter Sullivan | August 12, 2015  The Obama administrati […]
  • RSS Glenn Beck

    • An error has occurred; the feed is probably down. Try again later.